Friday, April 29, 2011

Confucius Vanishes From Tiananmen Square

We couldn't have been more surprised when the statue of Confucius suddenly appeared at Tiananmen in the first place. And set right across from and facing Mao Zedong! It's arrival was stunning, but understandable and promising. It is now almost as surprising that the Confucius statue has suddenly disappeared.

But it's disappearance is more ominous, more dispiriting. For it now appears the hard-line Maoist faction in China's leadership is still a notable force exerting influence on the Chinese Communist Party. If it is not powerful enough to blunt the progressive direction of China's economic and societal agenda, it is powerful enough--or has the potential to be disruptive enough--to halt such a public embrace of this singular symbol of what the Communist and Cultural Revolutions had stood so single-mindedly against: the institutionalized Confucian values and behavior system that formed the foundation for imperial China.

In a post to this website last January, "Confucius in Tiananmen Square," I offered this introduction to the appearance of the statue:
In recent correspondence, a friend offered some China news and a reflection about it:
"They just erected a 30 foot bronze statue of Confucius inTiananmen Square,facing the Mao Memorial. One of the rallying cries of the May 4th Movement in 1919 was "Down with Confucius, Inc.!" a theme that has reverberated through the Cultural Revolution. Now that Confucius, Inc. has been dismantled, it is apparently safe to honor Confucius, Teacher."
Apparently not, or at least not so prominently, so boldly representing his "rehabilitated," resurgent self-confidence--his very presence in that place heralding the eclipse of Mao. More than the old-guard Maoist veterans could bear, no doubt.  But this does not mean that the advancing national program to reclaim and teach Confucian values and identity is imperiled. Reporting has indicated that across venues and levels, the program is embraced and supported by the broader Chinese leadership. Let's hope that is true. And in 2012, there is scheduled a broad-based changing of the guard among the oldest, senior-most leadership of the government and military, offering further basis for hopefulness. The announced ascendency of Xi Jinping to succeed Hu Jintao as General Secretary and President marks the rise of yet another, even younger generation of more pragmatic, progressive leaders in China--and they will likely be replacing a number of the older, hard-line Maoist. At least, that appears likely.

So, it is not unreasonable to expect that in a few years the statue of the old sage may again make his appearance at Tiananmen Square. But next time, we can hope it will be more open, more triumphant--that the leadership and people may feel safer, more empowered, to stand there with him, acknowledging that Confucius appropriately, perhaps necessarily, occupies a place as close to the heart of Chinese identity as anyone else.

At this time, China needs such symbols of identity, character, values and discipline as its leadership and people engage the considerable challenges to be faced in their global economic and societal ambitions. But in the short term, it is not at all clear what, if anything, will publicly follow from the statue's disappearance. Not surprising, perhaps, I've seen nothing in China Daily about it all yet. But the following article from the New York Times.com shares what they know about the statue's disappearance, and reports what they've heard about why it likely happened and what it means. From the NYT: 
   BEIJING — ...The sudden disappearance of Confucius, which took place under cover of darkness early Thursday morning, has stoked outrage among the philosopher's descendants, glee among devoted Maoists and much conjecture among analysts who seek to decipher the intricacies of the Chinese leadership's decisions. Although there were some reports that the statue had been moved to a less prominent location within the newly expanded National Museum, those who had a hand in bringing Confucius to the ceremonial heart of the capital were of little help Friday. Tian Shanting, a spokesman for the museum, which had unveiled the statue with great fanfare, said he had no idea what had happened. The sculptor, Wu Weishan, declined to comment, as did city officials who have jurisdiction over Tiananmen Square... 
The statue's arrival in January at the museum entrance, cater-corner from the iconic portrait of Mao Zedong, set off a maelstrom of speculation, with many scholars describing it as a seismic step in the Communist Party's rehabilitation of Confucianism. In his day, Mao condemned that system of philosophical thought as backward and feudal; during the decade of the Cultural Revolution, Red Guards were encouraged to deface Confucian temples and statues. The scholar's ancestral home was destroyed, and bodies of long-dead descendants were exhumed and publicly displayed.  
But that was then. Eager to fill the vacuum left by the fading of Maoist ideology, the party in recent years has been championing Confucianism as a national code of conduct, with special emphasis on tenets like ethical behavior, respect for the elderly, social harmony and obedience to authority. Since 2004, the government has opened more than 300 Confucius Institutes around the world to promote the country's "soft power."  
Some academics say that placing a mammoth paean to Confucius a stone's throw from Mao's mausoleum may have gone too far. Chen Lai, a Confucian studies expert at Tsinghua University, suggested that those in the influential Central Party School who opposed the statue's placement near the square had been quietly agitating against it...Unrepentant Maoists celebrated the move on Friday. "The witch doctor who has been poisoning people for thousands of years with his slave-master spiritual narcotic has finally been kicked out of Tiananmen Square!" one writer, using the name Jiangxi Li Jianjun, wrote on the Web site Maoflag.net.  
For those who have been heartened by the government's embrace of Confucian values, news of the statue's removal was devastating. Guo Qijia, a professor at Beijing Normal University who helps run the China Confucius Institute, said that only Confucian teachings could rescue China from what he described as a moral crisis.  
--"Confucius Statue Vanishes Near Tiananmen Square," by Andrew Jacobs, The New York Times.com (4.22.11)  
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/23/world/asia/23confucius.html

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

An Education Solution: Balanced, Year-Round Schooling

One of the biggest problems with U.S. education may be summer vacations. That's what research and empirical evidence is telling us. There are still issues with teachers and unions, of course; there are certainly disagreements about curriculum and accountability; but it is the long, superannuated summer vacation that has proved a principal factor in both the gap in learning between children from low-income and higher income families, and America's slipping international ranking. And the reason is that students not intellectually challenged in the summer, especially those least engaged, forget a lot of what they learned in the last school year, and as many as six weeks or more of review can be required each returning year.

For some time now, I've been reading articles or references to research that indicate the significance of this problem, the possibilities to remedy it, and the barriers to getting that done. From a 2010 Time magazine article:
[W]hen American students are competing with children around the world, who are in many cases spending four weeks longer in school each year, larking through summer is a luxury we can't afford. What's more, for many children--especially children of low-income families--summer is a season of boredom, inactivity and isolation. Kids can't go exploring if their neighborhoods aren''t safe. It's hard to play without toys or playgrounds or open spaces. And Tom Sawyer wasn't expected to care for his siblings while Aunt Polly worked for minimum wage.

Dull summers take a steep toll, as researchers have been documenting for more than a century. Deprived of healthy stimulation, mllions of low-income kids lose a significant amount of what they learn during the school year. Call it "summer learning loss," as the academics do, or "the summer slide," but by any name summer vacation is among the most pernicious--if least acknowledged--causes of achievement gaps in American schools. Children with access to high-quality experiences keep exercising their minds and bodies at sleepaway camp, on family vacations, in museums and libraries and enrichment classes. Meanwhile, children without resources languish on street corners or in front of glowing screens. By the time the bell rings on a new school year, the poorer kids have fallen weeks, if not months, behind. And even well-off American students may be falling behind their peers around the world.
 
--"The Case Against Summer Vacation," by David Von Drehle, Time (8.2.10)
That's the story, and the evidence is pretty strong. But do not take from this that children of better-off families who enjoy more active, interesting or challenging intellectual experiences in the summer, do not suffer from the same effect; it is just less pronounced. And children from better-off families are also more likely to have parents who are college graduates who expect and focus on academic success. They encourage summer reading and learning experiences. Their home environment is more likely to be a source of intellectual stimulation. But that still doesn't compensate for an unavoidable measure of "summer learning loss" for them too, as the months-long summer vacation distances them from last year's studies. And that level of learning loss likely contributes to the performance advantage of students in the year-round education systems of many foreign countries.

But let's consider some of the findings that contribute to the case against summer vacations. More from the Time article:
The problem of summer vacation, first documented in 1906, compounds year after year. What starts as a hiccup in a 6-year-old's education can be a crisis by the time that child reaches high school. After collecting a century's woth of academic studies, summer-learning expert Harris Cooper, now at Duke University, concluded that, on average, all students lose about a month of progress in math skills each summer, while low-income students slip as many as three months in reading comprehension, compared with middle-income students. Another major study, by a team at Johns Hopkins University, examined more than 20 years of data meticulously tracking the progress of students from kindergarten through high school. 
The conclusiuon: while students made similar progress during the school year, regardless of economic status, the better-off kids held steady or continued to make progress during the summer--but disadvantages students fell back. By the end of grammar school, low-income students had fallen nearly three grade levels behind, and summer was the biggest culprit. By ninth grade, summer learning loss could be blamed for roughly two-thirds of the achievement gap separating income groups.
So, it's a no-brainer, right? We need only balance and extend the school year for all American students; we just take some pages from the school calendars of the most competitive countries, right? Uh, no. There are a number of forces arrayed against a year-round school calendar, including middle- and higher-income families. And then there are teachers, unions, and financial constraints, as well. No, this is not an easy sell, not broadly, not right away it seems. And in most places it is not even possible right now.

But the experience and experiemental research in many private and charter school environments have led more and more public school systems to ask the serious questions, and many to make the commitment to change to a year-round calendar. A recent case in point was Indianapolis IN:
Two days before Thanksgiving, the Indianapolis School Board will make a decision sure to heat up discussion around the turkey in just about every home with young children. That's when board members will vote on whether to adopt year-round classes. If the board approves the measure, Indianapolis pupils would go to school in cycles of eight to 10 weeks, with three to five weeks off after each, throughout the year. That would put them among the growing number of children around the nation who are going to school on so-called balanced schedules.  
Indianapolis Superintendent Eugene White said the schedule would add 20 class days every year, giving pupils more time to learn and shorter periods away from the classroom to forget what they've studied. For both teachers and students, the shorter but more frequent breaks will "give them some kind of relief and (allow them to) come back more invigorated," he said. That's important in a district criticized for low standardized-test scores and high dropout rates, said board member Annie Roof, because "what we are doing isn't working."  
10 percent by 2012? 
If the board approves, Indianapolis will hop on a bandwagon that's quietly rolling across the education landscape. Ten years ago, according to Education Department statistics, about 1.5 million public school children went to class on a "balanced schedule"--usually shorthanded as YRE, for "year-round education." Six years ago, that number was up to 2 million. By 2008, nearly 2.5 million pupils were on a YRE plan. But since then, some of the nation's biggest districts have adopted or expanded YRE in their facilities, notably the Chicago Public Schools, and others--including Houston and Indianapolis--could join them next year. By 2012, education groups estimate, more than 5 million pupils--about 10 percent of all children enrolled in American public schools--could be going to school year-round. 
'We don't have them here enough' 
"Society can't keep saying to schools 'have every kid perform better' when we don't have them here enough," said Charlie Kyte, president of the Minnesota Association of School Administrators. A few Minnesota districts have adopted balanced calendars, and many others are studying the idea.  
In Indianapolis, the difference is clear in the small number of schools that are already year-round, said Margaret Silk, a fourth-grade teacher at one of them, Ernie Pyle Elementary School. There, 70 percent of students from low-income families pass their state assessment tests, higher than the Indiana average for all students and well above the average for lower-income students. Silk said that under the traditional calendar, it took six weeks of reviewing the previous year's lessons just to get her students back up to speed. "In this calendar, oh, my goodness, (it takes) maybe two weeks at most," she said.  
---"Year-round school gains ground around U.S.: Shorter but more frequent vacations could slow 'spring slide'," by Alex Johnson, msnbc.com (10.27.2010)
If then, so many private initiatives have successfully ventured into summer learning programs for the willing, and some public systems or schools have also successfully embarked on more year-round calendars as well, why wouldn't Indianapolis follow suit? After all, it has worked well, just as the research indicated it would. And more broadly, why isn't year-round education taking root even faster? From the msnbc.com article:
For one thing, it's not just pupils who don't like the idea of sitting in class all day in the middle of summer. Public opinion polling has consistently shown that a majority of American adults oppose mandatory summer classes, too.The most recent poll, by Rasmussen Reports in July, found that adults opposed a year-round calendar by 63 percent to 31 percent--about the same ratio as other surveys taken in recent years. (The Rasmussen poll reported a margin of sampling error of 3 percentage points.) 
Specifically, 71 percent of adults — parents and non-parents alike — said in the most recent poll that children learn valuable life lessons during long summer breaks, by going to camp or by taking temporary jobs. And at public hearings recently in Indianapolis, some parents complained that summer classes would complicate their family vacation plans.  
But the big objection boils down to this: "Show me the money," Randy J. Greene, superintendent of schools in Paducah, Ky., said when the idea was raised there after Obama's comments last month. Year-round buses and lunches and after-school tutoring programs cost more, Greene said, and parents are already unhappy about a 4 percent increase in property taxes to cover the $300,000 cut in state funding that hit the district this year.
Nevertheless, in November 2010, Indianapolis approved implementation of the proposed "balanced," year-round public school calendar. Progress continues. But for the majority of those other places where parents, unions and budgets deny full-scale YRE calendars, why not take a page out of some of the private ventures and at least provide an extended school year--a summer session--for those less well-off students? Well, first, it is unlikely that a school system could or would require attendance by one income group that is not required of all. And then there are still the budget issues.

Even if parents and unions reverse field--and they likely will, eventually--the financial crisis, and the resulting stress on state and municipal budgets, has caused many school systems like Paducah, KY, to delay consideration, and others to delay implementation of plans already approved. Las Vegas provides an example of the latter. From the same msnbc.com article:
The cost concern is playing out differently in Las Vegas, where the Clark County School Board--facing a $30 million shortfall in its budget thanks to reduced state funding and declining property tax revenue--voted in April to abandon a year-round calendar and return to the traditional three-month summer break. The new calendar was projected to save the district about $13.8 million.  
Marcie McDonald, principal of Squires Elementary School, said she understood that the board had to try to balance its smaller budget. But she said doing so would come at a real cost. Ninety-two percent of McDonald's pupils are Latino, and for two-thirds of them, English is their second language. "Our little ones are learning language," McDonald said. "They go home and listen to their primary language of their home for three months and come back. And having not used English for three months--that poses another concern or problem."
So, if the progress continues, if the positive experience of some schools and school systems is strengthening the case for the rest, extraordinary budgetary constraints are clearly slowing that progress. The question is, when will the financial situation right itself? But also, when will the majority of Americans recognize that the individual, community and national interest in a more effective, more competitive educational system calls for embracing a balanced, year-round school calendar? As we've seen, the realization that well-off students would also benefit, albeit to a lesser extent than the least well-off, often does not appear a compelling consideration to their parents. And issues of discrimination or differential treatment would likely deny any initiative to require an extended school year only for those less well-off students. In some of those cases, might alternatives approaches eventually prove availing?

In those more challenging situations, another strategy might be to approach the challenge one step at a time. A summer session might first be offered on a voluntary basis, but where teachers and counselors are required to make clear to all families and students the educational and competitve advantages of attending--especially in terms of competitive job markets and admissions to colleges (and in appropriate cases, performance against international standards). The advantages would be particularly emphasized to those families and students most in need; but the competitive advantage would also be pointed out to those most aspiring students. As a combination of the most responsible and ambitious students from all income groups increasingly attend the summer session, other middle- and upper-income students will likely be drawn in as well--out of concern for falling behind competitively, if nothing else. Then there would likely result the strongest de facto case for requiring summer session attendance by all students. Where appropriate, it may provide another way to get from here to there.

In closing, let me assure you I understand that year-round education is but one of several issue to be addressed in improving American education. We need more able, well-trained, effective and committed teachers. And yes, self-serving teachers unions will have to be denied a material role in matters of education policy. But a more balanced year-round school calendar is nonetheless an important contributing problem. And if we are to more effectively address the higher-income, lower-income performance gap, while advancing the competitive learning of higher-income students as well, then all school systems will eventually have to find the civic will to require year-round education--and the means to finance it. It should be coming to your town, and mine too. It has to.

Read more:
http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,2005654-1,00.html
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/39748458/ns/us_news-life/

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

An Intuition, A Way and Understanding

Psalm 23 
The Lord is my shepherd,
I shall not want. 
He makes me lie down
in green pastures;
He leads me beside
quiet waters.
He restores my soul. 
He guides me
on the paths of righteousness
for His name's sake. 
And even though I walk through the
valley of deep darkness,
I fear no harm;
for You are with me.
Your rod and Your staff,
they comfort me. 
You prepare a table before me
in the presence of my enemies.
You have annointed my head with oil.
My cup runs over. 
Surely goodness and lovingkindness
will follow me
all the days of my life,
and I will dwell
in the house of the Lord,
forever.

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

The Bible Is Dead; Long Live the Bible--And Other Provocations

First, from Timothy Beal in The Chronicle Review:
For many potential Bible readers, the expectation that the Bible is univocal is paralyzing. You notice what seem to be contradictions or tensions between different voices in the text. You can't find an obvious way to reconcile them. You figure that it must be your problem. You don't know how to read it correctly, or you're missing something. If the Bible is God's perfect, infallible Word, then any misunderstanding or ambiguity must be the result of our own [failings]. So you either give up or let someone holier than thou tell you "what it really says." I think that's tragic. You're letting someone else impoverish it for you, when in fact you have just brushed up against the rich polyvocality of biblical literature. 
The Bible is anything but univocal about anything. It is a cacopho­ny of voices and perspectives, often in conflict with one another. In many ways, those dedicated to removing all potential biblical contradictions, to making the Bible entirely consistent with itself, are no different from irreligious debunkers of the Bible, Christianity, and religion in general. Many from both camps seem to believe that simply demonstrating that the Bible is full of inconsistencies and contradictions is enough to discredit any religious tradition that embraces it as Scripture.  
But you can't fail at something you're not trying to do. To ask whether the Bible fails to give consistent answers or be of one voice with itself presumes that it was built to do so. That's a false presumption, rooted no doubt in thinking of it as the book that God wrote. On the contrary, biblical literature is constantly interpreting, interrogating, and disagreeing with itself. Virtually nothing is asserted someplace that is not called into question or undermined elsewhere. Ultimately it resists conclusion and explodes any desire we might have for univocality. 
We don't know, and will never know, many details about the history of the development of biblical literature. No doubt there have been countless hands, scribal and editorial, involved in writing, editing, copying, and circulating the various versions of various texts that eventually were brought together into a canonical collection. Nor do we know very much for certain about the ancient life situations—ritu­al practices, oral traditions, legal systems—in which these texts had their beginnings. Nor do we know everything about the complex process by which the canons of Jewish and Christian Scriptures took form. What we do know for certain is that the literature now in our Bibles was thousands of years in the making. 
Given how many hands have been involved in so many contexts over such a long time in the history of this literature, can we honestly imagine that no one noticed such glaring discrepancies? Can we believe, for example, that the seam between the first and second creation stories in Genesis, as well as the many other seams found throughout the Torah, were not obvious? That if agreement and univocality were the goal, such discrepancies would not have been fixed and such rough seams mended long ago? That creation stories would have been made to conform or be removed? That Job would've been allowed to stand against Moses? That Gospel mix-ups concerning who saw what after Jesus's resurrection would have been left to stand? That Judas would have died twice, once by suicide and once by divine disgorge? And so on. Could all those many, many people involved in the development of biblical literature and the canon of Scriptures have been so blind, so stupid? It's modern arrogance to imagine so. 
The Bible canonizes contradiction. It holds together a tense diversity of perspectives and voices, difference and argument—even, and especially, when it comes to the profoundest questions of faith, questions that inevitably outlive all their answers. The Bible interprets itself, argues with itself, and perpetually frustrates any desire to reduce it to univocality. 
---"The Bible is Dead; Long Live the Bible," by Timothy Beal , professor of religion at Case Western Reserve University, The Chronicle Review (4.17.11)
 I sent a link to the article excerpted above to several friends and acquaintences, including a few friends who have neither read the Bible nor have any desire to do so. One, a very able, good and selfless civic contributor, a person I like, allowed that she would read the article on my recommendation. This would not likely have been something she gravitated to unprodded.

It's just that so many good folks won't read the Bible because of the types of expectations and limitations impliedly placed on the experience by very "religious" people on the one hand, and very "athiestic" anti-Diests on the other. But there is a more intelligent middle ground for reading and understanding the history of the Bible and what it has to say, both for spiritual seekers and the merely interested or curious. It can be a fertile ground for open-minded exploration in faith, but also a wonderful experience in fascinating literature and cultural history. For some of us--a fair number of us, actually--it is both.

The article shares a refreshing understanding of the unencumbered, open-minded and challenging venture into the rich, but often ambiguous experience it can offer. Like all good educational processes, it raises as many questions as it answers, and the answers as often as not reveal different understandings when seen through different perspectives, contexts and times. Like the life experience it addresses, it is often complex and confounding, and defies simple answers or understandings. It is anything but what many people want it to be.

I sent the article to some who have no interest in reading the Bible, not to entice them to read it--although I think they could be enriched by the experience. (And it is a notoriously difficult book to make sense of by just picking it up and randomly reading.) Rather, it was my hope just to share this third perspective on reading and understanding the Bible, an open-minded, open-hearted exploration of either spirituality, faith, literature or cultural history. And as much, to make clear that some of us who claim some variation of a faith journey read it with the same accountability and intellectual honesty with which we pursue other experiences and aspects of our lives that challenge understanding.

But at the risk of wandering off the reservation, I also must share that I have always been a student of human behavior. And a walk in spiritual exploration or faith--an accountable walk--must also be taken with eyes and mind wide open for what existential life and scientific research tell us about who we are, what we do, and why. My studies in psychology, genetics, brain, neural and endocrine systems as an undergraduate (and through a graduate fellowship) have remained active areas of interest for me throughout my life-- and for some years, evolutionary science, as well. And I believe there is ample evidence to suggest that our personalities and temperaments have a lot to do with our orientation to spirituality and faith. We can see those personality types reflected in the range of both political and faith expressions.

And the likely level of determinism involved can be unsettling--more so to some than others, but to some extent to all. For our genetic prescriptions and predispositions appear to govern far more of who we are and what we do than we are comfortable acknowledging. And the deterministic power of our family, educational and cultural conditioning is also greatly at odds with our preferred understandings and sense of freedom, choice, and self-determination. Very uncomfortable, ambiguous stuff for most people--just as uncomfortable as Mr.Beal's shared understandings and approaches to experiencing the Bible are to most believers.

Such ambiguity and challenges to identity are so much of what life offers. I too think it a shame if the discomfort of wrestling with them keeps us from exploring and better understanding the determinants and possibilities of our identity. And to ignore those invitations and challenges may also be to fall short of our potential.

http://chronicle.com/article/The-Bible-Is-Dead-Long-Live/127099/?sid=cr&utm_source=cr&utm_medium=en

Friday, April 15, 2011

Just Right: Obama's Budget Speech

President Obama's response to the Republican budget--and all it's draconian implications--was for me just right. Yes, it was as much a policy speech and campaign speech as a budget speech. It had to be as he effectively articulated the differences in his approach from that of the Republican's plan--a plan that had more an ideological agenda than a budget agenda. He made it clear he is ready to fight for the healthier socio-economic balance our country expects and needs, and our people deserve.

While we must move quickly and effectively toward a balanced budget, we must also protect and invest in America's people and future. Social programs--including social security, Medicaid and Medicare--will have to be reformed to make them both effective and cost-efficient. Health care policy will have to be more realistic, and provided more cost-efficiently. Defense spending will have to be rethought, reined in, and right-sized. And tax code reform will also be necessary, including restoring higher effective tax levels, especially on higher-income Americans. Obama will not be a party to placing a heavier, unworkable retirement and healthcare cost burden on our next generation of seniors.

This excerpt from NBC's First Read on-line sums up well the audiences the President was addressing and the messages he delivered:
*** Obama's three audiences: President Obama's deficit/debt/entitlement speech yesterday appeared to have three audiences. Those elusive independent voters were his first audience, and he told them he would cut the budget but with balance and sacrifice for all.     
Democratic liberals upset by Friday's spending-cut deal and December's tax-cut deal made up a second audience. To them, Obama gave a full-throated defense of the safety-net programs and vowed he would sunset the tax cuts for the wealthy. 
Republicans were his final audience. To them, he skewered their proposal to phase out Medicare and to keep those tax cuts for the wealthy. And Obama delivered another message to the GOP: It was under their party's previous president and GOP-controlled Congress that began racking up the deficits. In short, the speech was as much about defining the GOP budget plan -- coming before the House votes on the Ryan proposal on Friday -- as it was checking the box on addressing the deficit and debt.  
---"First Thoughts: Off and running," First Read from NBC News (msnbc.com), NBC's Chuck Todd, Mark Murray, Domenico Montanaro, and Ali Weinberg (4.14.11)
Going into the speech, I thought that the President had to give us more detail on the budget, but I was wrong. I underestimated the need and his ability to deliver a strong, effective speech that builds his policy statement as he touches all the important bases, a speech that gives enough detail to make his points, but does not lose sight of policy essentials and the big picture. A strong and important speech, a good beginning. Now let the budget debate and the presidential campaign begin in earnest.

Friday, April 1, 2011

...and now Libya.

Iraq, Afghanistan, and now Libya. Let your mind and heart and emotions speak to you; let the realities of our experience and history inform you; let your highest hopes and worst fears have their say, too. And whether all that offers up joy, despair, bewilderment, or a confusion of all three, let's at least hope for an end sooner rather than later, a more representative government, a better society for Libya resulting--and at the lowest possible cost of life and resources.

And may we learn whatever there is to learn from it all. Our collective sense of national discernment can use all the insight, wisdom and refinement our experience and history offers.

As for me, I share the humanitarian values and goals that motivate President Obama. But the experience and lessons of Iraq and Afghanistan cast a long, cautioning shadow over the best intentions and hopefulness that animate this intervention in Libya. I am not optimistic; I expect a longer, more painful and expensive process than NATO plans. Still, we are there, and I join everyone else who hopes and prays those best intentions are realized.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

America's Decline: Too Inflexible to Readapt and Reinvest?

Throughout my career in corporate America, I was always dismayed and discouraged by the cyclical narrowness and myopia of the corporate cost-cutters. Not that periodic efficiency measures weren't called for, they were. But it was too often done in frantic, thoughtless and irresponsible ways. The worst were the unthinking, across-the-board, percentage cuts. Too often it was not about "best practices" that gave primacy of place to considerations of quality and customer; it was about short-term earnings and financial statements. But the best companies appear to have gotten much better at that over the decades, and they are better off for it. 

The next lessons learned involved understanding who they were as companies, what their particular, even unique compentencies and strengths were. You can't plan and grow if you don't understand who you are and why. Next, and very important, were they investing in the success of tomorrow by investing in the next generations of today's technologies and what may be tomorrow's? And most important, perhaps, were they investing in their people, in their training and advancement? For the future is increasingly about intellectual capital, competence, and leadership. A company's value, its service to its shareholders, constituencies and the economy, is as much about the value being created for the future as the value being reaped today. And tough decisions about critical trade-offs require leaders to act responsibly for future generations as much as they provide for today's.

I find it hard to look dispassionately at our greatest nation of the 20th century, America, without looking through the same lens, without being attentive to the same issues and dynamics. For surely the same principles, questions and concerns are appropriate in how we view America today and how we contemplate her future, our grandchildren's future.

One of the best articles I've read on this subject, one that best captures and reflects some of my concerns, is Are America's Best Days Behind Us? in the 3.14.11 issue of Time magazine. It is written by the ever-insightful Fareed Zakaria, who recently moved from Newsweek to Time and brought with him his considerable depth of knowledge and talent. I have chosen to reproduce almost the entire article here simply because almost all of it bears reading--and he says it better, more efficiently than I can paraphrase it. Mr. Zakaria:

I am an American, not by accident of birth but by choice. I voted with my feet and became an American because I love this country and think it is exceptional. But when I look at the world today and the strong winds of technological change and global competition, it makes me nervous. Perhaps most unsettling is the fact that while these forces gather strength, Americans seem unable to grasp the magnitude of the challenges that face us. Despite the hyped talk of China's rise, most Americans operate on the assumption that the U.S. is still No. 1.
But is it? Yes, the U.S. remains the world's largest economy, and we have the largest military by far, the most dynamic technology companies and a highly entrepreneurial climate. But these are snapshots of where we are right now. The decisions that created today's growth — decisions about education, infrastructure and the like — were made decades ago. What we see today is an American economy that has boomed because of policies and developments of the 1950s and '60s: the interstate-highway system, massive funding for science and technology, a public-education system that was the envy of the world and generous immigration policies. Look at some underlying measures today, and you will wonder about the future.
The following rankings come from various lists, but they all tell the same story. According to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), our 15-year-olds rank 17th in the world in science and 25th in math. We rank 12th among developed countries in college graduation (down from No. 1 for decades). We come in 79th in elementary-school enrollment. Our infrastructure is ranked 23rd in the world, well behind that of every other major advanced economy. American health numbers are stunning for a rich country: based on studies by the OECD and the World Health Organization, we're 27th in life expectancy, 18th in diabetes and first in obesity. Only a few decades ago, the U.S. stood tall in such rankings. No more. There are some areas in which we are still clearly No. 1, but they're not ones we usually brag about. We have the most guns. We have the most crime among rich countries. And, of course, we have by far the largest amount of debt in the world.
The Rise of the Rest
Many of these changes have taken place not because of America's missteps but because other countries are now playing the same game we are — and playing to win. There is a familiar refrain offered when these concerns are raised: "We heard all this in the 1980s. Japan was going to dominate the globe. It didn't happen, and America ended up back on top." It's a fair point as far as it goes. Japan did not manage to become the world's richest country — though for three decades it had the second largest economy and even now has the third largest. It is also a relatively small country. To become the largest economy in the world, it would have to have a per capita GDP twice that of the U.S. China would need to have an average income only one-fourth that of the U.S. to develop an economy that would surpass ours.
But this misses the broader point. The Harvard historian Niall Ferguson, who has just written a book, Civilization: The West and the Rest, puts things in historical context: "For 500 years the West patented six killer applications that set it apart. The first to download them was Japan. Over the last century, one Asian country after another has downloaded these killer apps — competition, modern science, the rule of law and private property rights, modern medicine, the consumer society and the work ethic. Those six things are the secret sauce of Western civilization."
To this historical challenge from nations that have figured out how the West won, add a technological revolution. It is now possible to produce more goods and services with fewer and fewer people, to shift work almost anywhere in the world and to do all this at warp speed. That is the world the U.S. now faces. Yet the country seems unready for the kind of radical adaptation it needs. The changes we are currently debating amount to rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.
Sure, the political system seems to be engaged in big debates about the budget, pensions and the nation's future. But this is mostly a sideshow. The battles in state capitals over public-employee pensions are real — the states are required to balance their budgets — but the larger discussion in Washington is about everything except what's important. The debate between Democrats and Republicans on the budget excludes the largest drivers of the long-term deficit — Social Security, Medicaid and Medicare — to say nothing of the biggest nonentitlement costs, like the tax break for interest on mortgages. [And let us not forget the DOD, one of the most distended budgets of them all.] Only four months ago, the Simpson-Bowles commission presented a series of highly intelligent solutions to our fiscal problems, proposing $4 trillion in savings, mostly through cuts in programs but also through some tax increases. They have been forgotten by both parties, in particular the Republicans, whose leading budgetary spokesman, Paul Ryan, praises the commission in the abstract even though he voted against its recommendations. Democrats, for their part, became apoplectic about a proposal to raise the retirement age for Social Security by one year — in 2050.
Instead, Washington is likely to make across-the-board cuts in discretionary spending, where there is much less money and considerably less waste. President Obama's efforts to preserve and even increase resources for core programs appear to be failing in a Congress determined to demonstrate its clout. But reducing funds for things like education, scientific research, air-traffic control, NASA, infrastructure and alternative energy will not produce much in savings, and it will hurt the economy's long-term growth. It would happen at the very moment that countries from Germany to South Korea to China are making large investments in education, science, technology and infrastructure. We are cutting investments and subsidizing consumption — exactly the opposite of what are the main drivers of economic growth.
So why are we tackling our economic problems in a manner that is shortsighted and wrong-footed? Because it is politically easy. The key to understanding the moves by both parties is that, for the most part, they are targeting programs that have neither a wide base of support nor influential interest groups behind them. (And that's precisely why they're not where the money is. The American political system is actually quite efficient. It distributes the big bucks to popular programs and powerful special interests.) And neither side will even talk about tax increases, though it is impossible to achieve long-term fiscal stability without them. Certain taxes — such as ones on carbon or gas — would have huge benefits beyond revenue, like energy efficiency.
It's not that our democracy doesn't work; it's that it works only too well. American politics is now hyperresponsive to constituents' interests. And all those interests are dedicated to preserving the past rather than investing for the future. There are no lobbying groups for the next generation of industries, only for those companies that are here now with cash to spend. There are no special-interest groups for our children's economic well-being, only for people who get government benefits right now. The whole system is geared to preserve current subsidies, tax breaks and loopholes. That is why the federal government spends $4 on elderly people for every $1 it spends on those under 18. And when the time comes to make cuts, guess whose programs are first on the chopping board. That is a terrible sign of a society's priorities and outlook.
The Perils of Success
...America's success has made it sclerotic. We have sat on top of the world for almost a century, and our repeated economic, political and military victories have made us quite sure that we are destined to be No. 1 forever. We have some advantages. Size matters: when crises come, they do not overwhelm a country as big as the U.S. When the financial crisis hit nations such as Greece and Ireland, it dwarfed them. In the U.S., the problems occurred within the context of a $15 trillion economy and in a country that still has the trust of the world. Over the past three years, in the wake of the financial crisis, U.S. borrowing costs have gone down, not up.
This is a powerful affirmation of America's strengths, but the problem is that they ensure that the U.S. will not really face up to its challenges. We adjust to the crisis of the moment and move on, but the underlying cancer continues to grow, eating away at the system.
A crucial aspect of beginning to turn things around would be for the U.S. to make an honest accounting of where it stands and what it can learn from other countries. This kind of benchmarking is common among businesses but is sacrilege for the country as a whole. Any politician who dares suggest that the U.S. can learn from — let alone copy — other countries is likely to be denounced instantly. If someone points out that Europe gets better health care at half the cost, that's dangerously socialist thinking. If a business leader notes that tax rates in much of the industrialized world are lower and that there are far fewer loopholes than in the U.S., he is brushed aside as trying to impoverish American workers. If a commentator says — correctly — that social mobility from one generation to the next is greater in many European nations than in the U.S., he is laughed at. Yet several studies, the most recent from the OECD last year, have found that the average American has a much lower chance of moving out of his parents' income bracket than do people in places like Denmark, Sweden, Germany and Canada.
And it's not just politicians and business leaders. It's all of us. Americans simply don't care much, know much or want to learn much about the outside world. We think of America as a globalized society because it has been at the center of the forces of globalization. But actually, the American economy is quite insular; exports account for only about 10% of it. Compare that with the many European countries where half the economy is trade-related, and you can understand why those societies seem more geared to international standards and competition. And that's the key to a competitive future for the U.S. If Olson is right in saying successful societies get sclerotic, the solution is to stay flexible. That means being able to start and shut down companies and hire and fire people. But it also means having a government that can help build out new technologies and infrastructure, that invests in the future and that can eliminate programs that stop working. When Franklin Roosevelt launched the New Deal, he spoke of the need for "bold, persistent experimentation," and he shut down programs when it was clear they didn't work. Today, every government program and subsidy seems eternal.
What the Founding Fathers Knew
Is any of this possible in a rich, democratic country? In fact it is. The countries of Northern Europe — Denmark, Sweden, Norway, Finland — have created a fascinating and mixed model of political economy. Their economies are extremely open and market-based. Most of them score very high on the Heritage Foundation's Index of Economic Freedom. But they also have generous welfare states and make major investments for future growth. Over the past 20 years, these countries have grown nearly as fast as, or in some cases faster than, the U.S. Germany has managed to retain its position as the world's export engine despite high wages and generous benefits.
Now, America should not and cannot simply copy the Nordic model or any other. Americans would rebel at the high taxes that Northern Europeans pay — and those taxes are proving uncompetitive in a world where many other European countries have much lower rates and Singapore has a maximum personal rate of 20%. The American system is more dynamic, entrepreneurial and unequal than that of Europe and will remain so. But the example of Northern Europe shows that rich countries can stay competitive if they remain flexible, benchmark rigorously and embrace efficiency.
American companies are, of course, highly efficient, but American government is not. By this I don't mean to echo the usual complaints about waste, fraud and abuse. In fact, there is less of those things than Americans think, except in the Pentagon with its $700 billion budget. The problem with the U.S. government is that its allocation of resources is highly inefficient. We spend vast amounts of money on subsidies for housing, agriculture and health, many of which distort the economy and do little for long-term growth. We spend too little on science, technology, innovation and infrastructure, which will produce growth and jobs in the future. For the past few decades, we have been able to be wasteful and get by. But we will not be able to do it much longer. The money is running out, and we will have to marshal funds and target spending far more strategically. This is not a question of too much or too little government, too much or too little spending. We need more government and more spending in some places and less in others.
The tragedy is that Washington knows this. For all the partisan polarization there, most Republicans know that we have to invest in some key areas, and most Democrats know that we have to cut entitlement spending. But we have a political system that has become allergic to compromise and practical solutions. This may be our greatest blind spot. At the very moment that our political system has broken down, one hears only encomiums to it, the Constitution and the perfect Republic that it created. Now, as an immigrant, I love the special and, yes, exceptional nature of American democracy. I believe that the Constitution was one of the wonders of the world — in the 18th century. But today we face the reality of a system that has become creaky. We have an Electoral College that no one understands and a Senate that doesn't work, with rules and traditions that allow a single Senator to obstruct democracy without even explaining why. We have a crazy-quilt patchwork of towns, municipalities and states with overlapping authority, bureaucracies and resulting waste. We have a political system geared toward ceaseless fundraising and pandering to the interests of the present with no ability to plan, invest or build for the future. And if one mentions any of this, why, one is being unpatriotic, because we have the perfect system of government, handed down to us by demigods who walked the earth in the late 18th century and who serve as models for us today and forever.
America's founders would have been profoundly annoyed by this kind of unreflective ancestor worship. They were global, cosmopolitan figures who learned and copied a great deal from the past and from other countries and were constantly adapting their views. The first constitution, the Articles of Confederation, after all, was a massive failure, and the founders learned from that failure. The decision to have the Supreme Court sit in judgment over acts of the legislature was a later invention. America's founders were modern men who wanted a modern country that broke with its past to create a more perfect union.
And they thought a great deal about decline. Indeed, it was only a few years after the Revolution that the worrying began in earnest. The letters between Thomas Jefferson and John Adams, as the two men watched America in the early 19th century, are filled with foreboding and gloom; you could almost say they began a great American tradition, that of contemplating decay. Americans have been concerned about the health of their country for much of its existence. In the 1950s and '60s, we worried about the Soviet Union and its march toward modernization. In the 1980s, we worried about Japan. This did us no harm; on the contrary, all these fears helped us make changes that allowed us to revive our strength and forge ahead. Dwight Eisenhower took advantage of the fears about the Soviet Union to build the interstate-highway system. John Kennedy used the Soviet challenge in space to set us on a path toward the goal of getting to the moon.
What is really depressing is the tone of our debate. In place of the thoughtful concern of Jefferson and Adams, we have its opposite in tone and temperament — the shallow triumphalism purveyed by politicians now. The founders loved America, but they also understood that it was a work in progress, an unfinished enterprise that would constantly be in need of change, adjustment and repair. For most of our history, we have become rich while remaining restless. Rather than resting on our laurels, we have feared getting fat and lazy. And that has been our greatest strength. In the past, worrying about decline has helped us avert that very condition. Let's hope it does so today.

Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Humility & Respect on the Spiritual Continuum

The truth is that many folks--very good folks, in fact--never share in the spiritual or faith experiences I sometimes describe, whether they are open to it or not: they sense no God; they are disinclined toward faith; they reflect no spiritual intuition. To borrow context from my reflection, Being Found, they do not and never have sensed that
"...the One who calls us may be trying to get their attention." They have in no way perceived Him "waving His arms at them in the press of daily relationships and responsibilities, flashing His light in the soft, smiling eyes that pause and pass by, speaking in the voices of those who love and care, whispering to the heart that sighs, stirring in their very soul. They have not heard Him calling from all creation, the cycles of birth and death, change and renewal, nudging them to the questions of what is passing, what transcends, and what endures."
Perhaps they are too lost, too isolated or without, too much in pain or emotional suffering to lift their eyes or hearts in faith or even hope. People are wont to say that, even to believe it. Perhaps they are too much involved with self-indulgence or self-aggrandizement to consider a more disciplined, behavior-changing alternative. We hear that as well. Or perhaps they are just insensitive or unresponsive to spiritual invitations or cues for reasons unclear to us. And perhaps that is an expression of their personality or temperament, perhaps it is just the way they are genetically wired--for there is, apparently, a correlation between a group of genes and faith or spirituality.

But the inescapable corollary must be a call for humility and respect from each of us to all of us. And we must be aware that those of us who do reflect a spiritual intuition, who do sense God, hear the invitations, and have a personal experience of connectedness with something we call God, may also be reflecting something of our personalities and temperaments, our genetic predispositions or prescriptions. That does not mean there is no God--although some would consider it evidence--or, for we Christians, that Jesus is not still the same Jesus.* But it continues to challenge us all about the reasons some people are drawn to spiritual understandings and experience, and some are not. 

For the faithful, it also continues to challenge us about what God is doing in our lives, wherever we fall on the spiritual or faith continuum. Orthodox Christianity has no satisfactory answers for these questions, at least not for me--other than the notions of predestination and election, and the call to trust in God's perfect love and justice, notions that do not share comfortably the same intellectual or emotional space. Mystery or misunderstanding? Destiny or delusion? How about humility about the unknown and unknowable? Yes, humility, that at least. And respect, that too--for all people wherever they are, or are not, on that spiritual or faith continuum.

[*For those interested in my understandings of my faith and connectedness with God and Christ, see my essays "What God?", "Being Found" and others in my What God? series.]

No More Leaving


At some point
Your relationship with God
Will become like this:

Next time you meet Him
In the forest
Or on a crowded city street,

There won't be anymore
"Leaving."

That is,
God will climb into
Your pocket.

And you will simply
Take yourself
Along.

*from The Gift (1999), poetry ascribed to Hafez, as freely interpreted by Daniel Ladinsky.

Sunday, March 6, 2011

A Faith Understanding

There is a faith understanding reached by some, including some Christians, that the seeming paradoxes of determinism and free will, predestination and choice--and the related issues of justice and equity that we are sometimes inclined to prosecute with God--are reconciled in the assurance and trust that is ours when we more fully apprehend God's Love and Forgiveness. Then, more often, there is only gratitude and peace.
       

The Dark and Light of Faith and Love


The Heart is Right*

The heart is right
To cry

Even when the smallest drop of light,
Of love,
Is taken away.

Perhaps you may kick, moan, scream
In dignified
Silence.

But you are so right
To do so in any fashion

Until God returns
To you.


Brave in That Holy War*

You have done well
In the contest of madness.

You were brave in that holy war.

You have all the honorable wounds
of one who has tried to find love

Where the beautiful bird does not drink...

Come morning
I will kneel by your side and feed you.
I will so gently
Spread open your mouth

And let you taste something of the
Sacred mind and life.

Surely
there is something wrong
With your ideas of
God

If you think
If you think our beloved would not be so
Tender.


Just You and Me*

The closer
I get to You, Beloved,
The more I can see
It is just You and me alone
In this
World.

I hear
A knock at my door,
Who else could it be,
So I rush without brushing
My hair.

For too many nights
I have begged for Your
Return.
And what
Is the use of vanity
At this late hour, at this divine season,
That has now come to my folded
Knees.

If your love letters are true dear God,
I will surrender myself to
Who you keep saying
I am.


*from The Gift (1999), poetry ascribed to Hafez, as freely interpreted by Daniel Ladinsky.

Friday, February 25, 2011

The PRC's Ascendancy: More on Reasons Why


I have a long and earnest interest in China. I have my reasons, good reasons, I believe. Part of it goes way back to my days of military service during the Chinese Cultural Revolution, when I was trained and worked as a Chinese crytologic linguist under one of our national intelligence services. Part of it is my general interest in Chinese art and history which I explore through a group I belong to in Naples. China has a long, fascinating, and impressive history of unique achievement. But most important is the ascendant, global economic and geopolitical profile of a country that is already a force to be reckoned with in the world, the trajectory of which is toward greater, possibly dominating global influence.

I often don't understand why others don't share my depth of interest and concern. The result is that I sometimes find myself in passing conversations in which I am eagerly trying to relate my understandings. But in trying to share them in a short discussion, I can err on the side of passion, and fail to convey a properly qualified and measured summary explanation. In these situations, I can be a poor emissary for those understandings and concerns. Allow me to try to do better here.

As I have said, I am something of a student of China, or at least a China junkie. I read everything I can in both the Chinese and Western press, and in the most respected journals I can find. And in recent years I have had and spent more time indulging that interest. But now, my more recent and continuing readings on China's dynastic history have given me a new perspective on their most recent "lost century," followed by their stunning ascendency of the last 30 years. I now understand that China has many times reshaped or restructured itself over periods of at least a century--or much longer--in the 4800-year history of a continuing Chinese polity and culture. In the long view, I've come to see China's newest ascendency as just China recreating itself again, a view also shared by some China analysts and historians. And the substantial, increasing number of educated Chinese in the PRC, and there leaders, are well aware of their illustrious dynastic history and, like their forbears, are by temperament or discipline given to taking the long view.

If this assessment is at all true and fair, the prospects for China--and for America in a world with China so dramatically ascendant--should be sobering to us. We can continue to be a successful, powerful, and respected world player, but only if we understand the new game we are now playing and the new and changing contours of the field we are playing on. It is a world of evolving multilateralism and increasing collaboration--a world of more shared global decision-making and accountability. And China will be offered its place among the leaders, or it will ascend to it by virtue and authority of its increasing global economic strength and the mutual dependency of the US, the West and China upon each other. It appears an inevitability; its just a matter of how constructively, how wisely we move more toward that relationship. 

The best informed analysts and commentators I have read suggest that we must understand China well, and also understand our well-considered goals and related needs for the future. Then we must devote the best of our creative, industrious capability and work effort to collaborate, partner with China wherever common national and international interests are found and allow. Their consensus view is that to compete with China from a zero-sum posture for command of environmental technology or global natural resources, for example, will prove a costly miscalculation and mistake, one which will cause all to lose. In both those areas, but particularly in environmental technology, China is already well ahead of us both in investment and progress--and they have extended to us the invitation to join them in sharing information and working collaboratively in the future. But our response has been tepid, and those who have reponded meaningfully at all appear to be a few companies, a think tank or two and NGOs, but not the government.

And then there is my respectful view of the Chinese people. That view holds that they have substantial capacity and potential to continue their evolving and quickly advancing societal and economic ascendency. This is often an unwelcome view; it can sound too strong, too unqualified, and carry too much the ring of destiny for most American tastes. Some people are uncomfortable with the notion of genetic determinism, with its inherited prescriptions and predispositions; they like even less cultural or conditioned determinism, that we are to some extent also a product of our environment. Yet there is a strong measure of scientific reality to both. And the question is usually, rightly posited in terms of whether nature or nurture is more dominant in explaining individual, societal or cultural behavioral--not whether either is an invalid or inoperative factor in explaining that behavior. One would have a hard time challenging the tested conclusion that the Chinese people as a whole, the dominant Han people, are an intrinsically intelligent people. And they have millenia of continually layered culture, successful culture in governance, bureaucracy, the arts, military arts and conquest, and yes, inventiveness, even creativity.

It is also important to observe that there were occasions when failed Chinese leadership, financial mismanagement, or social instability so weakened them that they were "conquered"--by Western tribal powers, by nomads of the Mongolian steppes (Genghis Khan), and the last dynasty, the Qing, was led by the Manchus from the far Northeast. So, what did that mean for the coninuity of Chinese civilization, identity and potential?

The most interesting thing is that, in each instance, dynastic China continued on with the conquerors taking the throne as Chinese emperors, and continuing the Chinese civilization! The Chinese scholar-leader-bureaucrats most often continued to be employed in shared or supporting leadership roles. The military was rebuilt and reshaped to serve the new merged dynasty. They took a Chinese dynastic name to designate the period of their reign. And they eventually became de facto Chinese!

So the Mongols ruled over the Yuan dynasty, and the Manchus over the Qing. It is a fair observation, with the course of history to substantiate it, that China absorbed all people, ideas, religions and philosophies that entered into Chinese civilization--even those who entered by invasion--and made them Chinese. They accepted them, but changed them, and absorbed them into what is Chinese. Buddhism brought from India was merged with Taoist ideas and produced Chan Buddhism, which when exported to Japan was called Zen. Only Confucianism--really more a philosophy and ethic for personal and leadership behavior--and Daoism are indigenous philosophy/spiritualities in China. The Chinese civilization is really the long-term amalgamation of many peoples and ideas.

I would also suggest that in the same way China has taken all that comes into its civilization and made it Chinese, it is also internalizing and fashioning its own Chinese approach to an internal market economy and competing in global markets--it's market socialism or state capitalism, as it is called. We'll just have to see how effective their uniquely Chinese approach will prove. But so far they appear to have gotten the world's attention, and their economic progress has been impressive.

Yet, we have not seen as much of that inventiveness and creativity out of China in the last century or so--but that likely had more to do with the repressive, increasingly anti-intellectual, anti-mercantile, anti-modernity climate moving from the Nationalist Revolution to the Communist Revolution and to the Cultural Revolution. For the last 30 years, they have been lifting themselves out of that cultural, intellectual, economic and geopolitical abyss. And now, they have emerged again on the world stage. I expect their historical inventiveness and creativity will continue to emerge as well.

Of course, as some observe, each new generation, each new era is...well, new. And a new Chinese generation in a new era, especially a new and advancing technological era, a more global, multilateral era, would arguably be cutting more from whole cloth, beginning anew, especially coming out of their "lost century." That would also imply a steep, daunting learning curve. Fair point, and doubtless valid in many respects and effects, as far as it goes. But there is something important to be recognized and appreciated about the power and contribution of a deep and long cultural history, especially a history that experienced many amazing expansions and contractions, ascending again and again to the heights of global culture. It must be observed that the current situation falls consistently on China's multimillenial trend line, one which reflects the many times China has come out of a failed political or economical situation, followed by a warring and fragmenting century or longer, only to restructure and reinvent itself, and ascend still higher ground of societal, military and economic advancement.

This time may be different. China surely has many daunting challenges. It is possible they may be too great to overcome. But I wouldn't look at those challenges as welcome or calming justifications to discount China's potential, for failing to take them seriously enough, for not understanding and respecting their history. The US has the potential to do that. There is a certain amount of American arrogance and triumphalism--sometimes just rank demogoguery and jingoism--that does not recognize shifting sands and the realities of a new environment. And our fledgling experience with democracy, a relative newcomer by historical standards, is as vulnerable as it is resilient. And it sometimes can prove near dysfunctional--or at the least very slow to act, and then to act only incrementally. Now appears to be such a time. Of course, historically we have always risen to the occasion in the face of threats to our people and way of life. But international economic competition and geopolitical maneuvering seldom appear as overtly and immediately threatening to us, not to the public, not in the same way as the military aggression of Germany and Japan before WWII, or of al Qaida on 9/11. And with the PRC, China, that is where the game is being played: global economic strength and power, and geopolitical influence.

Our government agencies (certainly the State Department and CIA) and the think tankers understand all this well enough, and likely much more. But most Americans do not. It would appear that many of our politicians do not either--or at least what we hear from them or their cable media proxies (and that's often all some people hear) appears filtered through the distorting prism of their ideological bias and/or their true lack of knowledge or understanding. For China's is a more responsive, effective and efficient governmental process than ours. Totalitarian governments can move more decisively, more quickly. It may or may not be as "good," depending on your definitions, your social values and goals. For it is unapologetically undemocratic, and its people are clearly less free; I wouldn't want to live there. But it is nonetheless very efficient, very effective. And their 30-year success in venturing into competitive, global markets is impressive--and their trajectory continues ascendant.

My concern is simply this: we should not underestimate the Chinese people or the Chinese government--and likewise we should not overestimate ourselves, especially in a weakened and confused time. Rather, let China's ascendancy be as a wake-up call for America, a challenge to claim and move to new, higher ground ourselves. Let us invite China to more meaningfully join in shared global leadership, responsibility and accountability. And if we would claim democracy as the high ground of social and economic advancement and potential, now is our time to bring out our best and prove it.

I just wanted you to understand.